Where Eagles and Herons Watch Dogs (32KB)

Bob Bailey

Pavlov is Always Sitting On Your Shoulder

Post to ClickerSolutions, a Yahoo Group

Copyright © 2001 by Robert E. Bailey
All Rights Reserved

Pavlov sitting on your shoulder

by Bob Bailey

As posted to ClickerSolutions
Slightly edited
Used with permission

Sun, 2 Sep 2001 06:36:27 -0500
Copyright 2001 by Robert E. Bailey.
Thanks to Bob Bailey for permission to post this article.

To: ClickerSolutions@yahoogroups.com
From: "Bob & Marian Bailey" <behavior@hsnp.com>
Date: Sun, 2 Sep 2001 06:36:27 -0500
Subject: [CS] Pavlov sitting on your shoulder

Several have asked privately what I mean by Pavlov is (always) sitting on your shoulder. OK. Here is how I use it in our classes, as well as how I "live it."

No matter where we are in training; no matter where our focus is on "getting" behavior; no matter at what level the sophistication is of the animal:

The animal is a sentient being, with a long history of biological (including behavioral) evolution that has given it built-in emotional states and responses that may, at any time, be elicited by environmental circumstances.

Further, depending on the animal's experience (its antecedents), those emotional responses may be powerful enough to override any operant responses you have conditioned, and even more, those you are in the process of conditioning.

Any time the trainer forgets the animal has fears, anxieties, and other potentially diminshing emotional responses, the trainer is open to a rude awakening.

Such emotional conditions are usually reflected in the animal's expressed behaviors, including rates of various behaviors emitted, body language, vocalization, or the lack of it, etc. The emotional outburst may [even] be violent.

However, seldom does an animal just suddenly go bonkers. Usually, if the trainer is sensitive and experienced, the animal will signal that things are not going well emotionally. Part of our skill at our craft is being able to hear and see what the animal is expressing. If we are so focused on the behavior we are after, and the animal is reacting to something in the environment that is causing distress and we don't see that emotional response, we may find that the subject behavior suddenly (though, not really suddenly; we just failed to notice) deteriorates and the animal may give one or more very untoward responses.

The point here is that Pavlov on your shoulder is an always condition; it never goes away. We may lessen it by various means, but it is never gone, and the trainer must forever be aware of it.

Pavlov on your shoulder is one of the "facts of life" that can humble the best of trainers. For those of us who have worked with large wild animals, our recognition of this has often saved us some physical trauma.

I hope this helps those who asked.

    --Bob Bailey

Original Message*

Back to top

*What clicking on "Original Message" does

Clicking on the "Original Message*" link will take you directly to the original message under the following conditions:

1) you are a member of the group in which the message was posted

2) you are already signed in to Yahoo

3) the Yahoo server on which the message is located is operating

If you are not signed in to Yahoo at the time you click on "Original Message*," Yahoo will prompt you to sign in, but then, it may, obstreperously, lose track of where you came from, which nullifies the effect of the link you clicked on to see the original message.

To get around that little problem, after you sign in to Yahoo, you may use your browser's Back button to return to the page where you clicked on "Original Message*," and click there again.

That procedure should take you to the original message within the group.

However, if Yahoo happens to be working on the server where the message is located, you will not gain access to the message. Just try again later.

Afterwards, if you wish to return to Coherent Dog again, you can again use your Back button, or, if you are using a tabbed browser, you may go through these procedures by opening different tabs for each different page.

Index to Articles

Back to top

You are CoDog number

counter ocr2

Last modified on
Saturday, 12-Jul-2008 14:36:10 PDT

It is now
Saturday, 16-Jan-2021 06:04:36 PST

valid css!
Valid XHTML 1.0!
Reflecting Stars
All material on this site except where noted is
Copyright © 1995-2014 by Carol Whitney. All rights reserved.
For reprint permissions, send email in plain text only, to Carol Whitney